Skip to main content

2020 Goals: Pie For Week 2 - Grandma Rosella's Vanilla Custard Pie

One of my favorite things to do is pick a topic, run to the library and check out tons of books on that topic and if I really like a particular book, I'll try to find them at my local Goodwill or on Thriftbooks to save some money.

Last year, knowing I wanted to challenge myself with making a pie a week for a year, I bought up several books and they will be featured on the blog as I make the pie recipes from them.

This week's recipe is taken from a book I found on Thriftbooks. Well, of course you know there is a story here! I chose a used book on Amazon from a Thriftbooks location and when it got here, I realized the entire section for making the pie crusts had been torn out so carefully you couldn't tell it was missing until you went looking for them. Luckily for me, when I wrote this company they sent me out another copy that is GLORIOUS, even featuring an errata section in the front! They are one of the BEST used book dealers out there you guys! If you want to do 2nd hand shopping please check them out! You'll be glad you did! And the cookbook itself is full of stories, adorable pictures and unique tasty pie recipes full of fruit, custards, crumbles and even savory pies. I highly recommend it!

Anyway, my recipe this week comes from the book, Sweetie-Licious Pies Eat Pie, Love Life.

The Pie is called "Grandma Rosella's Vanilla Custard Pie" and it is on page 188. I'm not going to write the recipe here but I'll tell you it is full of milk, cream, eggs and egg yolks sugar and cornstarch flavored with both vanilla and almond extracts. The crust I used is also in the book and it is called the Sweetie-Licious Cream Cheese Crust. You can make the crusts up ahead of time and freeze them in the freezer until you intend to use them but I made it up fresh today. There is just a pinch of freshly grated nutmeg on the top. Once cooled, we'll chill it for a minimum of 3 hours before tasting.

Here is the Vanilla Custard Pie straight out of the oven. It turned out nice. Here is a word of advice; DO NOT LET YOUR CUSTARD OVERCOOK BECAUSE IT "LOOKS JIGGLY". Take a knife and run it in carefully at the center of your pie and pull it out. If the pie is done, there won't be any residue on your knife that looks like raw filling. If there is raw filling residue, cook your pie in 5 min. increments, testing each time for doneness. You could also turn your oven off and leave in the oven testing every 5 min. until done. Your pie will be a bit jiggly and that is a good thing. Once the pie cools on the countertop, we will put it into the refrigerator for a minimum of 3 hours and probably have it for dessert tonight.

My husband and I LOVE custard pies and this one is one of the best we've ever had! Definitely a two thumbs up from us! We ate it with some homemade whipped cream chilled to perfection and had trouble not going back for another piece! Yes, it was THAT GOOD!

That's it for this week. Come on back for more pie recipes and we'll share some more tips, tricks, tools and pie recipes.

My pie next week will feature some California Citrus. We are so lucky here on the Central Coast of California to have warmer winters than most people. Local Citrus is in season here and can be found at the Farmers Markets and at Cal Poly's "You Pick" orchards. With that in mind, I think next week's pie will be a lemon meringue or something with citrus in it.

Maybe you've always wanted to do something baking wise. This is a good little challenge to kind of push you out of your comfort zone. Make something for 52 weeks and take some pictures of your progress. You'd be amazed how practice makes perfect!!


Popular posts from this blog

Baby Shower Busy-ness

Ok, you probably thought I fell off the face of the earth right? Nope, there is just alot happening around here. The next event is Beckie's Baby Shower this Sunday. Decided to make my very first Diaper Cake and these are just a few of the pictures. The first thing I did was watch about 20 YouTube videos describing how to do it. Then I bought my supplies and put it together roughly first then more refined about a day later. This is a close up of the baby sock roses with mitten leaves. Yes, that video DOES exist! Next is a close up of wrist rattles and a little caterpiller radio that makes soothing sounds for baby. Background ribbon is from WalMart and the blanket set is from the Jungle Adventure Collection at K-mart. The topper for our "Jungle" themed cake is a Silver Back Ganz Gorilla . These little links slipped easily over the ribbon and added a little extra bling to the sides of the cake. Each layer consists of diapers along with extras like washcloths, burp pads and

Norwegian Pancakes (Norska Pannekaken)

Every culture has its pancake and this is the Norwegian version, a very light, crepe-like pancake that goes with just about anything. These "pancakes" are light and eggy and go with both sweet and savory fillings. When my chickens start up laying eggs in the Spring, we LOVE to make these pancakes, freezing the excess for another day. Yes, they freeze and thaw perfectly! Most people have the simple ingredients on their shelves and in their refrigerators SO LET'S GO! Original Recipe Can Be Found on the Outside Oslo Website   Here . Norska Pannekaken 3/4 cup all-purpose flour 1/4 teaspoon kosher salt 1 tablespoon sugar 1 teaspoon Scandinavian vanilla sugar* 3 eggs 1 1/2 cups whole milk 2 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted, plus more for pan Mix all ingredients except butter in a medium-sized bowl using a whisk or fork until the batter is smooth and you have no lumps. Stir in butter. Refrigerate for 30 minutes to let the batter rest. Meanwhile, warm a


Looky what came yesterday! My Word of the Year Necklace created by Lisa Leonard ! As the New Year approached I decided to choose a word that would define my upcoming year and I chose Gratitude. Around Thanksgiving, I set up my new blog, " I Am Thankful For..." and started keeping a daily journal of all the things I have to be Thankful, or Grateful for. Each day I would review my day in my head and list at least 5 things I had to be Grateful For. It has changed the way I approach each day tending to look for the positive instead of the negative in what life has to offer. If you'd like to find your word of the year, visit Christine Kanes' website  and pick a word of the year for yourself. Then I'd hop on over to the Lisa Leonard site and pick a wonderful necklace stating your intention for the year!